In Someone Else’s Shoes

This is a very well thought out presentation which speaks to each person’s complexity, the stories that go unsaid but float just beneath the surface. Titled “Empathy,” this video was presented by Cleveland Clinic’s CEO Toby Cosgrove at his annual State of the Clinic address on February 27, 2013. And it gets at a point that we all should take the time to consider: how new knowledge about the physical spaces of our lives can stress us, make us sick, or help us be well and connect with others.

OneLove

:::MME:::

The Problem of Ignorance:The Decline of Critical Thinking by Lawrence Davidson




In 2008 Rick Shenkman, the Editor-in-Chief of the History News Network, published a book entitled Just How Stupid Are We? Facing the Truth about the American Voter (Basic Books). In it he demonstrated, among other things, that most Americans were: (1) ignorant about major international events, (2) knew little about how their own government runs and who runs it, (3) were nonetheless willing to accept government positions and policies even though a moderate amount of critical thought suggested they were bad for the country, and (4) were readily swayed by stereotyping, simplistic solutions, irrational fears, and public relations babble.

Shenkman spent 256 pages documenting these claims, using a great number of polls and surveys from very reputable sources. Indeed, in the end it is hard to argue with his data. So, what can we say about this? One thing that can be said is that this is not an abnormal state of affairs. As has been suggested in prior analyses, ignorance of non-local affairs (often leading to inaccurate assumptions, passive acceptance of authority, and illogical actions) is, in fact, a default position for any population.
 
To put it another way, the majority of any population will pay little or no attention to news stories or government actions that do not appear to impact their lives or the lives of close associates. If something non-local happens that is brought to their attention by the media, they will passively accept government explanations and simplistic solutions.

 
The primary issue is “does it impact my life?” If it does, people will pay attention.  If it appears not to, they won’t pay attention. For instance, in Shenkman’s book unfavorable comparisons are sometimes made between Americans and Europeans. Americans often are said to be much more ignorant about world geography than are Europeans. This might be, but it is, ironically, due to an accident of geography. Americans occupy a large subcontinent isolated by two oceans. Europeans are crowded into small contiguous countries that, until recently, repeatedly invaded each other as well as possessed overseas colonies. Under these circumstances, a knowledge of geography, as well as paying attention to what is happening on the other side of the border, has more immediate relevance to the lives of those in Toulouse or Amsterdam than is the case for someone in Pittsburgh or Topeka.  If conditions were reversed, Europeans would know less geography and Americans more.

 
Ideology and Bureaucracy


The localism referenced above is not the only reason for widespread ignorance. The strong adherence to ideology and work within a bureaucratic setting can also greatly narrow one’s worldview and cripple one’s critical abilities.

 
In effect, a closely adhered to ideology becomes a mental locality with limits and borders just as real as those of geography. In fact, if we consider nationalism a pervasive modern ideology, there is a direct connection between the boundaries induced in the mind and those on the ground. Furthermore, it does not matter if the ideology is politically left or right, or for that matter, whether it is secular or religious. One’s critical abilities will be suppressed in favor of standardized, formulaic answers provided by the ideology.

 
Just so work done within a bureaucratic setting. Bureaucracies position the worker within closely supervised departments where success equates with doing a specific job according to specific rules. Within this limited world one learns not to think outside the box, and so, except as applied to one’s task, critical thinking is discouraged and one’s worldview comes to conform to that of the bureaucracy. That is why bureaucrats are so often referred to as cogs in a machine.

 
Moments of Embarrassment 


That American ignorance is explainable does not make it any less distressing. At the very least it often leads to embarrassment for the minority who are not ignorant. Take for example the facts that polls show over half of American adults don’t know which country dropped the atomic bomb on Hiroshima, or that 30% don’t know what the Holocaust was. We might explain this as the result of faulty education; however, there are other, just as embarrassing, moments involving the well educated. Take, for instance, the employees of Fox News. Lou Dobbs (who graduated from Harvard University) is host of the Fox Business Network talk show Lou Dobbs Tonight.  Speaking on 23 March 2013 about gun control, he and Fox political analyst Angela McGlowan (a graduate of the University of Mississippi) had the following exchange:

McGlowan: “What scares the hell out of me is that we have a president . . . that wants to take our guns, but yet he wants to attack Iran and Syria. So if they come and attack us here, we don’t have the right to bear arms under this Obama administration.”
Dobbs: “We’re told by Homeland Security that there are already agents of Al Qaeda here working in this country. Why in the world would you not want to make certain that all American citizens were armed and prepared?”

Despite education, ignorance plus ideology leading to stupidity doesn’t come in any starker form than this. Suffice it to say that nothing the president has proposed in the way of gun control takes away the vast majority of weapons owned by Americans, that the president’s actions point to the fact that he does not want to attack Syria or Iran, and that neither country has the capacity to “come and attack us here.” Finally, while there may be a handful of Americans who sympathize with Al Qaeda, they cannot accurately be described as “agents” of some central organization that dictates their actions.
Did the fact that Dobbs and McGlowan were speaking nonsense make any difference to the majority of those listening to them? Probably not. Their regular listeners may well be too ignorant to know that this surreal episode has no basis in reality. Their ignorance will cause them not to fact-check Dobbs’s and McGlowan’s remarks. They might very well rationalize away countervailing facts if they happen to come across them. And, by doing so, keep everything comfortably simple, which counts for more than the messy, often complicated truth.

 
Unfortunately, one can multiply this scenario many times. There are millions of Americans, most of whom are quite literate, who believe the United Nations is an evil organization bent on destroying U.S. sovereignty. Indeed, in 2005 George W. Bush actually appointed one of them, John Bolton (a graduate of Yale University), as U.S. ambassador to the United Nations. Likewise, so paranoid are gun enthusiasts (whose level of education varies widely) that any really effective government supervision of the U.S. gun trade would be seen as a giant step toward dictatorship. Therefore, the National Rifle Association, working its influence on Congress, has for years successfully restricted the Bureau of Alcohol, Tobacco, Firearms and Explosives from using computers to create a central database of gun transactions. And, last but certainly not least, there is the unending war against teaching evolution in U.S. schools. This Christian fundamentalist effort often enjoys temporary success in large sections of the country and is ultimately held at bay only by court decisions reflecting (to date) a solid sense of reality on this subject. By the way, evolution is a scientific theory that has as much evidence to back it up as does gravity.

 
Teaching Critical Thinking?


As troubling as this apparently perennial problem of ignorance is, it is equally frustrating to listen to repeated schemes to teach critical thinking through the public schools. Of course, the habit of asking critical questions can be taught. However, if you do not have a knowledge base from which to consider a situation, it is hard think critically about it.  So ignorance often precludes effective critical thinking even if the technique is acquired. In any case, public school systems have always had two primary purposes and critical thinking is not one of them. The schools are designed to prepare students for the marketplace and to make them loyal citizens. The marketplace is most often a top-down, authoritarian world and loyalty comes from myth-making and emotional bonds. In both cases, really effective critical thinking might well be incompatible with the desired end.
Recently, a suggestion has been made to forget about the schools as a place to learn critical thinking. According to Dennis Bartels’s article “Critical Thinking Is Best Taught Outside the Classroom” appearing in Scientific American online, schools can’t teach critical thinking because they are too busy teaching to standardized tests. Of course, there was a time when schools were not so strongly mandated to teach this way and there is no evidence that at that time they taught critical thinking. In any case, Bartels believes that people learn critical thinking in informal settings such as museums and by watching the Daily Show with Jon Stewart. He concludes that “people must acquire this skill somewhere. Our society depends on them being able to make critical decisions.” If that were only true it would make this an easier problem to solve.

 
It may very well be that (consciously or unconsciously) societies organize themselves to hold critical thinking to a minimum. That means to tolerate it to the point needed to get through day-to-day existence and to tackle those aspects of one’s profession that might require narrowly focused critical thought. But beyond that, we get into dangerous, de-stabilizing waters. Societies, be they democratic or not, are not going to encourage critical thinking about prevailing ideologies or government policies. And, if it is the case that most people don’t think of anything critically unless it falls into that local arena in which their lives are lived out, all the better. Under such conditions people can be relied upon to stay passive about events outside their local venue until the government decides it is time to rouse them up in some propagandistic manner.

 
The truth is that people who are consistently active as critical thinkers are not going to be popular, either with the government or their neighbors. They are called gadflies. You know, people like Socrates, who is probably the best-known critical thinker in Western history. And, at least the well-educated among us know what happened to him.

Lawrence Davidson is professor of history at West Chester University in West Chester PA.

OneLove

:::MME:::

Musings

Always trust yourself and your own feeling, 

as opposed to argumentations, discussion, 

or introductions of that sort; if it turns out that you are wrong, 

then the natural growth of your inner life will eventually guide you to other insights. 


Allow your judgments their own silent, undisturbed development, 

which, like all progress, must come from deep within 

and cannot be forced or hastened. 


Everything is gestation and then birthing. 

To let each impression and each embryo of a feeling come to completion,

 entirely in itself, in the dark, in the unsayable, the unconscious, 

beyond the reach of one’s own understanding, and with deep humility 

and patience to wait for the hour when a new clarity is born: 

this alone is what it means to live as an artist: in understanding as in creating.




~Rainer Maria Rilke

from Letters to a young poet, letter 3
OneLove
:::MME:::

How Capitalism Is Turning the Internet Against Democracy

http://www.democracynow.org/embed/story/2013/4/5/digital_disconnect_robert_mcchesney_on_how
Longtime media-reform advocate Robert McChesney looks at how the future of American politics could be largely determined by who controls the Internet in his newest book. “‘Digital Disconnect’ talks about the difference between the mythology of the Internet, the hope of the Internet, that it would empower people and make democracy triumphant, versus the reality, which is that large corporate monopolies and the government, working together, are taking away the promise of the Internet to suit their interests”. (SOURCE)

You can read the first chapter here:

http://www.scribd.com/embeds/134084834/content?start_page=1&view_mode=scroll

OneLove

 :::MME:::

Escaping The Herd

(sheeple)

 
Like many people who voted for Pres. Obama in 2008, I was upbeat that much needed changes were just around the corner. Pres. Obama’s soaring speeches gave us much to look forward to. Surely there were some successes in his first term such as the Lilly Ledbetter Fair Pay Act , the  Fair Sentencing Act , the Hate Crimes Prevention Act , broadband coverage to low-income rural families, Payment to Wronged Minority Farmers, the Children’s Health Insurance Authorization Act, repealed Don’t ask Don’t Tell, boosted fuel efficiency standards & increased support for veterans. That Pres. Obama was able to accomplish anything at all with such widespread animosity along racial/political lines is another thing one can add to the list of successes. All of these notable successes, however, are overshadowed by the darker powers that have always had control over the executive/legislative/judicial branches of government (since corporations became “people“). The list of Obama’s capitulation to these darker powers is a mile long, but the ones that really get under my skin at the present moment are:

(1)  Trans-Pacific Partnership (TPP)- This consequential trade pact has been described “NAFTA on steroids. ” With the U.S. and 10 other nations along the Pacific Rim, the TPP has the likely potential to increase offshoring of jobs to places like Vietnam and Malaysia. As highly profitable corporations seek larger profits through outsourcing, the casualties won’t just be the average blue-collar worker (at home and abroad), but the professional, white-collar U.S. worker as well. These people just don’t give a f*** about us, folks.Either Pres.Obama is oblivious or he’s drunk on the punch he’s been given.

(2) National Defense Authorization Act (NDAA) – Chris Hedges nailed it on the head in this article. Imagine a system of military justice that allows the military to police the streets of America to detain U.S. citizens & residents in military prisons – and these prisons could be here or abroad. Imagine no due process & a secret, lawless world of indiscriminate violence, terror and gulags – that’s what the NDAA stands for. So start crawling on your knees, wrap tape over your mouth & pretend not to know what is going on – it’s intended for you to stay quiet & distracted

(3) Whistleblower Protection Under Attack- The Obama Admin. has prosecuted more government whistleblowers  under the Espionage Act than any of the previous presidents combined. This prosecutorial abuse & overreach is outrageous when you look at the facts presented. Examine the cases of John Kiriakou, Bradley Manning, Thomas Drake, Aaron Swartz, Shamai Leibowitz…..The common denominator in all of these cases is conscience. We are living in a fateful era where the sacred rights of conscience is looked down upon with frightening and murderous contempt. Who could have predicted that a former community activist & constitutional scholar would one day attack the very foundations of the Constitution?

(4) The Drone Program- Pitch Interactive did a masterful job in creating a stunning infographic of every drone strike in Pakistan since 2004.  Of the estimated 3,100 people killed in those strikes, only 1.5% were identified by U.S. officials as “high-profile” targets, or suspected legitimate bad guys. The rest were children, civilians, and “other“ – those identified by the Obama administration as alleged combatants simply because they are adult males, regardless of what they may or may not have done. Evil.

(5) Free Trade Agreement w/ EU – Another giveaway to the big corporations to do whatever the hell they want to for profits. “The dirty little secret about [the US-EU negotiation] is that it is not mainly about trade, but rather would target for elimination the strongest consumer, health, safety, privacy, environmental and other public interest policies on either side of the Atlantic,” said Lori Wallach, director of Public Citizen’s Global Trade Watch. “The starkest evidence … is the plan for it to include the infamous investor-state system that empowers individual corporations and investors to skirt domestic courts and laws and drag signatory governments to foreign tribunals.”..These fuckers are dirty.

(6) Monsanto Protection Act – Did you catch the in-your-face signing of the Monsanto Protection Act? And do you recall Obama’s promise to “immediately” label GMOs upon his election? In case you are not up to speed, Monsanto, for nearly two decades has exercised monopolistic control over American agriculture (aided and abetted of course by bent-over politicians and regulatory agencies, supermarket chains, giant food processors, and the so-called “natural” products industry). While the EU bans  bio-engineered food, we in the US are totally at the mercy of what they put into our food supply. No one knows what the long-term effects are with regards to this tampering, but consider the statement made by Norman Braksick,  president of Asgrow Seed (a subsidiary of Monsanto): “If you put a label on genetically engineered food you might as well put a skull and crossbones on it.” Millions around the world are protesting against Monsanto’s demonic overreach, but Obama seems not to care or is too timid to challenge their power. 

It is way past time to disengage ourselves from this creepy cult of personality & critically examine what is going on both domestically and internationally in our name. Although Pres. Obama inherited a house in shambles & has had to deal with the most vitriolic attacks on his person (mainly because he is black), this should not disable us from turning up the heat. At the same time, we have to understand  that the problem is not simply his policy choices- the real problem, in my opinion, is corporate power & greed which surround him & our fledgling democracy – and if we are not careful, will destroy us all if we don’t wake up & raise our voices……

OneLove

:::MME:::